Categories: Bitcoin Politics

Butterfly Labs Urges Court to Dismiss FTC’s ‘Self-Serving’ Fraud Charges

Click here to view original web page at

Embattled mining hardware company Butterfly Labs has filed a motion to dismiss a Federal Trade Commission (FTC) complaint against the company.

Butterfly Labs (BFL) was shut down by the FTC last month following numerous claims of public misrepresentation and downright fraud.

However, in spite of nearly 300 customer filings against the company, BFL still insists it is the victim of overzealous regulators and intends to resume limited operations in the near future.

The sentiment is evident in the opening remarks of the latest filing, in which the company alleges the FTC headed a "campaign to destroy" BFL, following an "ask questions later" script. The company says the FTC created a "legal morass" by selectively using "self-serving" evidence.

See the full legal document at the bottom of this article.

Evidence challenged

The filing challenges evidence used in the case and accuses the FTC of lacking even basic information about the company, thus "depriving the court of an accurate and factual background".

"Plaintiff could have learned (if it didn’t already know), for example ... that BF Labs voluntarily ended its preorder sales on July 17, 2014 (rendering much of the prospective relief sought by Plaintiff moot)," the company stated in the filing.

Other evidence is disputed as well, such certain customer complains, claims about the volume of BFL shipments, previous complaints filed against the company and the FTC's media claims about the company, in which Butterfly Labs was described as a "bogus company of scammers."

The company pointed to the FTC's own decisions as proof that such characterisations made no sense:

"The same day that Plaintiff issued its press release calling BFL a 'bogus' company of 'scammers,' two of Plaintiff’s attorneys held a Twitter-feed Q&A session about the BFL case. In that session, the attorneys stated that BFL took  'at least $20 million, and potentially up to $50 million' from customers, and stated that 'thousands of orders were placed, and thousands of consumers have complained about non-delivery.' Yet six days later, Plaintiff agreed to permit BF Labs, the 'operation' that Plaintiff proclaimed to the world (and this Court) had taken between $20 and $50 million from thousands of customers, to reopen for limited operations."

Delays 'have precedent'

BFL went on to note that its "anticipated shipping dates" were not a misrepresentation of the facts, because no reasonable bitcoin-mining consumer could have concluded that anticipated shipping date and product development representations made by the company were either material or misleading.

BFL argued that reasonable investors should have anticipated possible delays or unforeseen product developments, citing several precedents involving tech companies. The company maintained that it merely disclosed the status of products under development and that its "shipping date and product development representations were immaterial and not misleading as a matter of law".

BFL went on to list a number of revisions, updates and blog posts in which it communicated the delays to its customers and the general public.

The company also criticised the FTC's decision to cite the use of a third-party bitcoin calculator on the BFL site, as the FTC failed to note that the output of the calculator was dependant on the value of bitcoin and the shipping date.

In its conclusion, the BFL legal team requests that the court "dismiss the complaint in its entirety and with prejudice".

Court documents image via Shutterstock


Butterfly LabsFTCLaw

Butterfly Labs (BFL) was shut down by the FTC last month following numerous claims of public misrepresentation and downright fraud.

However, in spite of nearly 300 customer filings  against the company, BFL still insists it is the victim of overzealous regulators and intends to  resume limited operations  in the near future.The sentiment is evident in the […]


Illuminati, Mason, Anonymous I'll never tell. I can tell you this, global power is shifting and those who have the new intelligence are working to acquire this new force. You matter naught except to yourself, therefore prepare for the least expected and make your place in the new world order.

Disqus Comments Loading...
Published by

Recent Posts

CME Group Reveals Plan for Bitcoin Options in Q1 2020

Leading derivatives exchange operator, CME Group announced in a press release today that it will launch options on its bitcoin… Read More

4 hours ago

Analyst: Bakkt Launch to Improve Trustworthiness of Crypto Markets

For the past year many participants within the crypto markets have been looking towards the official launch of Bakkt as… Read More

4 hours ago

IBM Stock Gets a Blockchain Pop

IBM (NYSE: IBM ) investors haven’t had all that much to complain about in 2019. After a precipitous drop over… Read More

4 hours ago

I-Team: Bitcoin scams rob Triangle investors of $54K

RALEIGH, N.C. (WTVD) -- A series of online heists is robbing even the most tech-savvy people in the Triangle.According to… Read More

4 hours ago

Colombia is slowly moving toward Bitcoin-friendly regulations

To say Colombia doesn’t have the best cryptocurrency regulations in the world would be an understatement. As it stands, crypto,… Read More

4 hours ago

Ethereum price analysis: Bulls take full control of ETH/USD

ETH/USD went up from $218.55 to $220.60. The Relative Strength Index (RSI) indicator is trending in the overbought zone. ETH/USD… Read More

4 hours ago

This website uses cookies. We use these cookies to collect data about your interaction with our website for the purpose of continuously improving your experience with our site. For more information we encourage you to read our privacy policy.

Read More