Categories: Bitcoin Business

US Copyright Office: No ‘Truth’ Behind Craig Wright’s Bitcoin Satoshi Claim

Click here to view original web page at www.ccn.com
The US copyright office has compellingly confirmed it has not investigated Craig Wright's claim that he is Satoshi Nakamoto- bitcoin's pseudonymous creator.

By CCN: Australian entrepreneur Craig Wright shocked the cryptocurrency community on Tuesday by filing copyright registrations over the Bitcoin whitepaper and early Bitcoin code. In a press release, Wright claimed the US Copyright Office had officially “recognized” his role as the true bitcoin creator.

The Copyright Office hit back last night with an official statement debunking the claims. In it, they explain that a copyright registration is not a “determination of truth.” It simply represents a claim over works. The Copyright Office does investigate the validity of those claims.

“As a general rule, when the Copyright Office receives an application for registration, the claimant certifies as to the truth of the statements made in the submitted materials. The Copyright Office does not investigate the truth of any statement made.”

This is nonsense. There's literally no such thing as being "awarded a copyright" under US law. The only real benefit of registering with the Copyright Office is the right to sue for statutory damages & attorney's fees. Craig Wright's copyright registration is meaningless theater. https://t.co/hQ0xrX0Tv2

— Jake Chervinsky (@jchervinsky) May 21, 2019

As one lawyer engaged in the crypto space, Jake Chervinsky, said, Craig Wright’s copyright registration is “meaningless theater.”

Anyone can file a copyright claim over the bitcoin whitepaper

As CCN alluded to in our initial reporting, and subsequent commentary, Craig Wright’s copyright registration is not proof of ownership. It is not evidence he is Satoshi Nakamoto, nor that he wrote the bitcoin whitepaper.

As the Copyright Office explains:

“A registration represents a claim to an interest in a work protected by copyright law, not a determination of the truth of the claims therein.”

Craig Wright filed a copyright registration for the Bitcoin whitepaper https://t.co/aIvg2BbmL2 pic.twitter.com/TVdU62TRRv

— Neeraj K. Agrawal (@NeerajKA) May 21, 2019

Anyone else could submit a claim over the Bitcoin whitepaper, just as Craig Wright did. If that happened, a Federal court, not the Copyright Office, would investigate the claims:

“It is possible for multiple, adverse claims to be registered at the Copyright Office… Disputes over the claims in a registration may be heard before federal courts, including disputes over authorship of a work.”

Craig Wright may be subject to penalties for false copyright claims

The Copyright Office explains that false copyright claims may be subject to penalties.

“Someone who intentionally includes false information in an application may be subject to penalties.”

Despite claiming he created Bitcoin, Wright has yet to provide hard evidence to back it up. Per the Copyright Office statement, all Wright did was “confirm” he was the author behind the pseudonym Satoshi Nakamoto. No evidence, just written confirmation.

“[We] asked the applicant to confirm that Craig Steven Wright was the author and claimant of the works being registered. Mr. Wright made that confirmation.”

As many commentators point out, the real Satoshi would simply need to sign a message with the private key associated with the Genesis block, the first bitcoin block ever mined.

Cooler heads prevail

Some initially panicked that Craig Wright’s copyright claim held significant weight. CNBC crypto analyst Ran NeuNer worried it would stop people using it without Wright’s agreement.

I think the Crypto world is grossly under estimating the implications of the latest move by Craig Wright. If he is awarded the copyright for the code and white paper he could stop people from using it without agreement. This is a scary thought.

— Ran NeuNer (@cryptomanran) May 21, 2019

However, he was quickly reminded that Bitcoin was released under an MIT License. As CCN explained, it’s one of the most permissive licenses. CoinCenter’s executive director Jerry Brito also brought sensibility to the issue, reminding followers that registering a copyright is nothing more than “signing a form.”

Registering a copyright is just filing a form. The Copyright Office does not investigate the validity of the claim; they just register it. Unfortunately there is no official way to challenge a registration. If there are competing claims, the Office will just register all of them. https://t.co/YA70ALpG1Y

— Jerry Brito (@jerrybrito) May 21, 2019

cinerama

Illuminati, Mason, Anonymous I'll never tell. I can tell you this, global power is shifting and those who have the new intelligence are working to acquire this new force. You matter naught except to yourself, therefore prepare for the least expected and make your place in the new world order.

Disqus Comments Loading...
Share
Published by
cinerama

Recent Posts

It’s Expiry Friday, Will Bitcoin’s Price Fall Once More?

In precisely five days, the September fiat settled bitcoin futures contract at CME expires.Yes, another month is nearly over, so… Read More

6 hours ago

‘Big Four’ Auditor Deloitte to Let Employees Buy Lunch with Bitcoin (BTC)

The “Big Four” auditing firm, Deloitte’s Luxembourg unit is working on letting its employees pay for lunch using cryptocurrency, especially… Read More

6 hours ago

Patrick Byrne Sells Overstock Shares for Crypto and Precious Metals

Patrick Byrne , the former chief executive of Overstock.com who sent shockwaves through the blockchain community not too long ago… Read More

6 hours ago

Canada’s Bit Farms Buys More Than 2,000 Mining Machines

Bit Farms, a cryptocurrency mining company stationed in Canada , has bought more than 2,000 new A10 Avalon mining machines… Read More

6 hours ago

Key Economic Indicators Due This Week a Gauge of Consumer Strength

In addition to economic data, the stock market anticipates comments from dovish St. Louis Fed President James Bullard this week.… Read More

6 hours ago

Digital assurance: The “Killer app of Blockchain” according to VeChain

Digital assurance: The "Killer app of Blockchain" according to VeChain According to Sunny Lu, the co-founder, and CEO of VeChain,… Read More

6 hours ago

This website uses cookies. We use these cookies to collect data about your interaction with our website for the purpose of continuously improving your experience with our site. For more information we encourage you to read our privacy policy.

Read More