Categories: ICO

Monumental: Federal Court Rules Case in Favor of Crypto ICO Against SEC

Click here to view original web page at www.ccn.com
Advertisement

Last week, the U.S. federal court ruled a case between the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and a crypto initial coin offering (ICO) project called Blockvest in favor of the ICO project.

Marco Santori, the president and chief legal officer at Blockchain, said:

“The SEC brought an enforcement action against a company called Blockvest, alleging that Blockvest’s ICO was a securities offering. SEC asked the court for a preliminary injunction (an order freezing Blockvest’s assets, among other things) so it called a hearing on the evidence.”

The SEC failed to justify that the ICO in question was actually a security and the court refused to acknowledge the token as a security solely based on the distribution method of the asset.

Precedent For the Market

The unexpected decision of the federal court is not necessarily a loss for the SEC nor a huge victory for the cryptocurrency sector. As SEC chairman Jay Clayton said, most ICOs that investors in the market talk about are mostly considered securities under existing U.S. regulations.

But, the outcome of the case established a precedent for the market and with some technicalities, some ICOs could potentially challenge the SEC in court and win a case if supported by sufficient evidence.

Access, security, and
transparency. Get a loan to get
cash for your crypto
Ad
SaltLending
Learn more

The SEC and investors in ICOs could also become more cautious in filing a lawsuit against an ICO project, as the court requires the plaintiff to explicitly describe the nature of the asset as a security, unaffected by the method in which the asset was introduced to the market.

“According to the court, in the ICO context there must be a ‘risk of financial loss’. This supports the proposition that something like an airdrop, by itself, cannot be a securities offering, even if the airdropped tokens are pre-functional. Admittedly rare today but possible,” Santori said.

The Blockchain executive, who operates the most widely utilized cryptocurrency wallet platform in the world, added that the federal court “went out of its way” to reject the argument from the SEC that the mere act of distributing an asset through an airdrop or a token sale is a security as it doubled down on its stance that a token offering in itself is not a security.

An important element of the case was the requirement of the court to the SEC to prove that an investor bought the token because the investor was offered the security directly by the issuer. For instance, if an investor in an ICO is to file a lawsuit against the project, the investor will need to prove, somehow, that the investor invested in the token sale directly by looking at the website, whitepaper, or some other information offered by the issuer.

More Complex to Sue an ICO

The recent federal court ruling created a more complex environment for both the SEC and investors in ICOs to challenge the issuer of a token and to claim that a token is a security based on U.S. regulations.

Santori added that the precedent established by the Blockvest case has raised the bar for any plaintiff seeking to sue ICO issuers:

“As my colleagues in twitter law have stated, SEC pretty much got what it wanted with regard to Blockvest. No bloody noses here. The precedent, though, is lasting, and definitely raises the bar for any plaintiff – public or private – seeking to sue ICO issuers. It’s going to be more complex, I think, than any of us realized. And a lot gets lost in the world of ICOs, like remembering.”

Featured image from Shutterstock.

Get Exclusive Crypto Analysis by Professional Traders and Investors on Hacked.com. Sign up now and get the first month for free. Click here.

cinerama

Illuminati, Mason, Anonymous I'll never tell. I can tell you this, global power is shifting and those who have the new intelligence are working to acquire this new force. You matter naught except to yourself, therefore prepare for the least expected and make your place in the new world order.

Disqus Comments Loading...
Share
Published by
cinerama

Recent Posts

$10K Bitcoin Stronger Than Ever But No One Seems to Care: Google Trends

Risk Disclaimer - By using this web site you agree to its terms and conditions. All materials, including but not… Read More

5 hours ago

Bitcoin Is A Hedge Against Gov’t “Fiscal Irresponsibility”, Analyst

Equities portfolio manager turned crypto fund executive Travis Kling has argued that Bitcoin has come into its own as a… Read More

5 hours ago

Why Are France & Germany Blocking Facebook’s Crypto? The Euro, Apparently

For those most part, governments have ignored Bitcoin . While the crypto asset’s proponents see it as the future of… Read More

5 hours ago

U.S. Charges JPMorgan Suits for ‘Spoofing’ Precious Metals Markets

| Source: Lorimer Images/Shutterstock The United States Department of Justice has charged three gold and precious metals traders from JPMorgan… Read More

5 hours ago

Your Crypto Exchange Can’t Send Even $1000 Without Exposing You

Regulator-compliant crypto exchanges are required to share your information with other financial institutions. | Source: Horth Rasur/Shutterstock Transferring more than… Read More

5 hours ago

Bigger Bloodbath in U.S. Stock Market Likely: Factors of Further Downtrend

Geopolitical risks and an uncooperative Fed could trigger a short-term relapse in stock prices. | Image: Shutterstock The U.S. stock… Read More

5 hours ago

This website uses cookies. We use these cookies to collect data about your interaction with our website for the purpose of continuously improving your experience with our site. For more information we encourage you to read our privacy policy.

Read More