Categories: Bitcoin Business

The Lightning Network Might Now Need a Token

Click here to view original web page at

The Lightning Network (LN) is to soon get watchtowers with the release of version 0.7 LND at an undisclosed date sometime this June.

Initially altruistically, the watchtowers are to see if anyone is trying to double spend by replaying an old transaction.

As you may know, LN doesn’t quite solve the double spending problem except through a game-theory mechanism whereby the network punishes an attempted double spender, but that’s only if someone is watching.

That’s why for now you have to be online all the time if you’re using LN, with the proposed solution here being that you can delegate this to a watchtower.

The watchtower has costs, particularly in regards to storage, so the plan is to implement some sort of fee charging mechanism followed by allowing individuals to pre-pay for backups of previous transactions which are necessary if you want to punish the double spending replayer.

“When it is integrated, it will probably resemble a Chaumian scheme where you pay via Lightning to acquire blinded tokens redeemable at the tower,” Conner Fromknecht, head of cryptographic engineering at Lightning Labs, said according to the Bitcoin Magazine.

They’re arguing this token might be desirable for privacy as it could potentially be designed in a way that the payment to the watchtower is not linkable.

This would be done through some sort of whitelisting as watchtowers could then “authenticate users up front but from then on it wouldn’t be able to pinpoint which users are renewing or backing up to the tower” according to Fromknecht because the tokens would be “blinded” and payments can’t be traced to a particular user.

The Chaumian scheme was used in eCash in the late 90s, an attempted digital fiat currency that used RSA blind signatures to achieve unlinkability between withdrawal and spend transactions.

Why a token would be needed here isn’t too clear, with some debate ongoing among LN devs regarding whether it would be the right approach.

A bigger concern would be who watches the watchers, with no clear solution so far unless of course you have some sort of Poof of Work or Proof of Stake mechanism in a blockchain of sorts.

Nor is it clear why bitcoin developers are not learning from some advances in eth in particular where snarks, and now even the starks, are being employed for scalability as innovative approaches have led to solutions that can significantly compress transactions with little tradeoff.

That could be far more superior than LN which is hardly finding much use with its total network capacity at just 950 BTC now a year on since it launched with the average channel capacity standing at just $200.

That might be because the main use case for bitcoin for now is the transfer of value. One off, in many cases large, payments that arguably wouldn’t benefit very much, if at all, from going to LN first especially considering its double spending problem.

There is also commerce with BitPay, for example, processing $1 billion worth of bitcoin a year according to the latest data from last year.

LN could play a role here, but starks could do it too at no cost and without double spending problems at least as far as it is currently known.

There is also TrueBit, which arguably deserves a bit more attention, with LN being one of the first conceptualization of transactions compression rather than the one and only solution.


Oncologists Are Freaking Out After True Cause Of Cancer Released

Initially altruistically, the watchtowers are to see […]


Illuminati, Mason, Anonymous I'll never tell. I can tell you this, global power is shifting and those who have the new intelligence are working to acquire this new force. You matter naught except to yourself, therefore prepare for the least expected and make your place in the new world order.

Disqus Comments Loading...
Published by

Recent Posts

CME Group Reveals Plan for Bitcoin Options in Q1 2020

Leading derivatives exchange operator, CME Group announced in a press release today that it will launch options on its bitcoin… Read More

6 hours ago

Analyst: Bakkt Launch to Improve Trustworthiness of Crypto Markets

For the past year many participants within the crypto markets have been looking towards the official launch of Bakkt as… Read More

6 hours ago

IBM Stock Gets a Blockchain Pop

IBM (NYSE: IBM ) investors haven’t had all that much to complain about in 2019. After a precipitous drop over… Read More

6 hours ago

I-Team: Bitcoin scams rob Triangle investors of $54K

RALEIGH, N.C. (WTVD) -- A series of online heists is robbing even the most tech-savvy people in the Triangle.According to… Read More

6 hours ago

Colombia is slowly moving toward Bitcoin-friendly regulations

To say Colombia doesn’t have the best cryptocurrency regulations in the world would be an understatement. As it stands, crypto,… Read More

6 hours ago

Ethereum price analysis: Bulls take full control of ETH/USD

ETH/USD went up from $218.55 to $220.60. The Relative Strength Index (RSI) indicator is trending in the overbought zone. ETH/USD… Read More

6 hours ago

This website uses cookies. We use these cookies to collect data about your interaction with our website for the purpose of continuously improving your experience with our site. For more information we encourage you to read our privacy policy.

Read More