Categories: Bitcoin Entertainment

Is Tim Swanson Right That Bitcoin Hoarding Is Bad?

Click here to view original web page at cointelegraph.com
Tim Swanson

Numbers blogger Tim Swanson recently used Bitcoin blockchain data graphs generated by John Ratcliff to declare that 70% of existing bitcoins have not been spent in six months.

He wrote that the data provides a “sobering chart” for those who want Bitcoin to grow. In his opinion, if all currency is not being spent like a hot potato—quickly hopping from one person to the next—this is a bad sign for a currency’s future value prospects.

For anyone familiar with economics, Swanson’s prescription is reminiscent of the claims of the famous but now largely discredited economist John Maynard Keynes. When Richard Nixon removed the US dollar from the last shreds of the gold standard in 1971, he said, “I am now a Keynesian in economics” (popularly misquoted as “We’re all Keynesians now”).

Since a popular name for Bitcoin is “gold 2.0,” it’s understandable that many proponents of Bitcoin would be against Keynesian economics. What were Keynes’ beliefs, exactly? Briefly, Keynes believed that wealth does not come from savings (capital), but rather from the simple act of spending. Specifically, it comes government-prompted mass spending due to inflationary fiat currency not pegged to scarce assets like gold. Keynes has since been discredited because the practice of his policies by the US Federal Reserve has caused a 98% decrease in the purchasing power of the US dollar since 1913.

Satoshi Nakamoto is, in a word, the anti-Keynes. Satoshi recognized that money that is consistently devalued over time causes a huge problem. It incentivizes people to spend quickly before the money loses more value, rather than thoughtfully saving it for the future. And a lack of savings keeps people in economic doldrums, because they can’t afford to finance startups, invest in innovations or weather unforeseen disasters. In other words, the hot potato spending encouraged by government money keeps poor people poor.

For this reason, Swanson’s sullen proclamation that people holding the majority of Bitcoin as capital is a bad thing can largely be dismissed to Keynesian thinking. Even Ratcliff, the graph-maker himself, disapproves of Swanson’s prescription and says so in the first comment on Swanson’s blog:

“Isn’t it true that more than 70% of all gold or even USD reserves in the world did not move during the same time frame[?] I look at the amount of value being transmitted on the network and think it is remarkable. Bitcoin is both a currency and a store of value, so what is unusual about the store being that high? I find it remarkable how much of the market is liquid.”

Tim Swanson may be good with numbers, but that doesn’t mean he’s good with economics.

Did you enjoy this article? You may also be interested in reading these ones:

Do more than buy & sell bitcoins. Boost your returns using up to 8x leverage and profit in rising or falling markets. Start investing from as little as $US10. Flexible to close out your position any time

He wrote that the data provides a “sobering chart” for those who want Bitcoin to grow. In his opinion, if all currency is not being spent like a hot potato—quickly hopping from one person to the next—this is a bad sign for a currency’s future […]

cinerama

Illuminati, Mason, Anonymous I'll never tell. I can tell you this, global power is shifting and those who have the new intelligence are working to acquire this new force. You matter naught except to yourself, therefore prepare for the least expected and make your place in the new world order.

Disqus Comments Loading...
Share
Published by
cinerama
Tags: one

Recent Posts

Tom Lee: Another Big Leap for BTC Is Coming

Well, it looks like Tom Lee is back in the news, and when you really think about it, why shouldn’t… Read More

5 hours ago

Graeme Moore Publishes Bitcoin Book for Kids

A new book has emerged to teach children about bitcoin. Known as “B Is for Bitcoin,” the book shows children… Read More

5 hours ago

Key Technical Indicator Signals Bitcoin is Gearing Up for a Big Move

After inching higher yesterday, Bitcoin faced a somewhat strong rejection at just above $10,400, which has brought the cryptocurrency down… Read More

5 hours ago

Day Trading is a Great way to get Rekt, Study Finds

Making money in the financial or cryptocurrency world isn’t as easy as one might think. The volatility of Bitcoin and… Read More

5 hours ago

Bitcoin Is ‘The Most Extraordinary Bubble of Our Generation’ Says Trader

The next bitcoin bull market is only getting started, analyst claims. | Source: Shutterstock Bitcoin is up by almost 180%… Read More

5 hours ago

The Story Behind ‘B is for Bitcoin,’ an ABC Book for Kids

While writing B is for Bitcoin , an ABC children’s book about cryptocurrency, author Graeme Moore had an epiphany—children don’t… Read More

5 hours ago

This website uses cookies. We use these cookies to collect data about your interaction with our website for the purpose of continuously improving your experience with our site. For more information we encourage you to read our privacy policy.

Read More